ARISE, O COMPATRIOTS vs. ON YOUR MANDATE WE SHALL STAND: WHERE IS THE CONSISTENCY?
34 viewsBy Frank Ofili
There is something rather curious about the controversy surrounding the singing of Nigeria’s former national anthem, Arise, O Compatriots, at the recent Nigeria Democratic Congress (NDC) town hall meeting in Lagos attended by Peter Obi.
Since the incident, some Nigerians have expressed outrage. Some have gone beyond condemnation to demand that those who sang the old anthem be punished. The Minister of Aviation, Festus Keyamo, has even demanded an explanation from the NDC leadership, while suggesting that the action could have implications for national unity and even secessionism.
Let me state from the outset that Nigeria has a legally recognised national anthem, and that anthem, following the National Anthem Act 2024, is Nigeria, We Hail Thee. Whether one agrees with the decision to restore the old independence anthem or not, the law is the law. That much is not in dispute.
But I have a question: Where does the law draw the line between the use of a song that is no longer the national anthem and the use of a political campaign song at official state functions?
Why are Nigerians being asked to condemn, threaten or even demand punishment for those who sang Arise, O Compatriots, while nobody appears particularly troubled by the regular rendition of On Your Mandate We Shall Stand at official functions to herald the arrival or presence of President Bola Ahmed Tinubu?
Let us be clear. On Your Mandate We Shall Stand is neither Nigeria’s national anthem nor a song enacted into law as a national symbol. It is, essentially, a political campaign song associated with President Tinubu. Yet, it has found its way into the ceremonial atmosphere of official government functions.
Indeed, there was a widely discussed controversy surrounding its rendition at the National Assembly, an institution that ought to represent all Nigerians, irrespective of political affiliation. The question is whether a song associated with the political campaign of an incumbent President should enjoy such prominence in official state ceremonies.
I am aware that the Minister of Aviation has offered a defence, arguing that On Your Mandate is not played in place of the national anthem but after the anthem has been rendered, as a ceremonial tune to usher in the President. Fair enough. But does that explanation completely resolve the question of political neutrality in the conduct of state institutions?
More importantly, if the argument is that singing Arise, O Compatriots at a political gathering amounts to disrespect for a national symbol, what principle of consistency permits a political campaign song to become part of the ceremonial identity of government?
Is the issue really about respect for national symbols, or is it about who is singing and whose political interests are involved?
If the law is to be respected, it must be respected by everybody. If the national anthem is sacrosanct, then its sanctity should not depend on whether the perceived offender belongs to the opposition or the ruling party. The same standard of scrutiny should apply to everyone.
I am not necessarily advocating that anybody should be punished for singing an old national anthem. Neither am I suggesting that On Your Mandate should be banned as a political song. Political parties and their supporters are entitled to have their songs, slogans and anthems. My concern is the apparent double standard in how these matters are interpreted and judged.
A national anthem belongs to the nation, not to a political party. And the Presidency is an institution of the Nigerian state, not an extension of the ruling party’s campaign headquarters. The National Assembly is also not an APC rally ground.
Perhaps those demanding punishment for the NDC supporters should first answer a simple question: If singing a former national anthem is an offence against the Nigerian state, what exactly is the justification for institutionalising the rendition of a ruling party’s campaign song at official government functions?
Or have we arrived at a point in our national life where the law is strict when it concerns the opposition but becomes flexible when it concerns the government?
That, to me, is the real issue.
